In 2022, US stocks and bonds fell in the same year. The episode shows the difference between where money sits and what it depends on to earn, with public data, sources and dates.
Diversification is usually explained as spreading money around: some in stocks, some in bonds, some in other currencies or countries. The idea is reasonable. If one part falls, another can hold up the whole. But it rests on an assumption that is rarely said out loud: that the parts do not depend on the same thing. When two investments depend on the same thing, being in different places does not stop them from falling together.
The year 2022 makes that assumption visible. This article describes what happened, with public data, and explains the mechanism.
Before reading
Athena did not exist in 2022; this is not an Athena result or a simulation. The figures are from public indices; the source and date of each are at the end of the article.
What happened in 2022
US stocks, measured by the S&P 500 with dividends reinvested, ended 2022 with a return of −18.11%. US dollar investment-grade bonds, measured by the Bloomberg US Aggregate index, ended with −13.01%. Globally, stocks did about the same: the MSCI ACWI index, which covers developed and emerging markets, closed the year at −18.36% (net return, in US dollars).
| Index | What it measures | 2022 return (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| S&P 500 (total return) | Large US companies' stocks | −18.11% |
| Bloomberg US Aggregate (total return) | US dollar investment-grade bonds | −13.01% |
| MSCI ACWI (net return) | Developed and emerging market stocks | −18.36% |
Since neither US index rose, splitting money between the two could not avoid the fall; it only changed its size. With positions left unchanged during the year, the fall would have been between −13.01% and −18.11%, depending on the proportion. (Athena's calculation: the annual return of a mix whose positions do not change during the year is the weighted average of its parts' returns. Costs, taxes and exchange rates are not included.)
Those falls coincided with high inflation and the response of central banks. In the United States, the consumer price index rose 9.1% in the twelve months to June 2022, the largest increase since November 1981, and ended the year at 6.5%. In Chile, the IPC rose 12.8% over 2022. The Federal Reserve raised its rate range for the first time in March, to 0.25%–0.50%, and by December had set it at 4.25%–4.50%.
Why they fell together
A bond pays fixed interest. When market rates rise, new bonds pay more, and a bond that already exists is worth less: for anyone to want it, its price has to fall. The longer its maturity, the stronger the effect. That is why a year of fast rate increases is, by simple arithmetic, a hard year for bonds already issued.
Stocks respond to the same force by another route. A company's value depends on the profits it is expected to generate in the future, brought back to today with a discount rate. If that rate rises, the same future cash flow is worth less today. High inflation also raises companies' costs and financing.
A common reading of 2022 is that the dominant cause was the same for both parts: high inflation and rates rising to contain it. Stocks and bonds were in different places, but in that episode they depended on the same thing.
Why in other episodes they offset each other
Bonds offsetting stocks is not a fixed property of bonds. It depends on what is moving markets. When the main concern is a weakening economy, central banks commonly cut rates. That tends to lift the price of existing bonds while stocks fall on lower expected profits. The two parts then react to different causes, and the mix cushions. When the main concern is inflation, as in 2022, the same force can push both in the same direction.
The relationship between two investments, measured by correlation, changes with the type of episode. It can be estimated from past data, but it does not stay fixed. This is typical behaviour, not guaranteed.
Where the money is, and what it depends on to earn
The episode leaves a distinction that is useful for reading any portfolio. One thing is where the money is: in which assets, countries or currencies. Another is what it depends on to earn: economic growth, the level of rates, inflation, the gap between two related prices, or a trend continuing.
Two parts can sit in very different places and depend on the same thing. And two parts in the same market can depend on different things. Describing a portfolio only by its percentages leaves out the question that explains how it behaves as a whole: what does each part need in order to earn, and in what situation does it lose?
Athena describes each of its strategies from that question: why it can earn and under what conditions it loses. Answering it does not remove losses. It shows in advance what they depend on.
What this episode does not say
One year is not a rule. 2022 shows a mechanism; it does not anticipate when it will happen again or how strongly. Nor does it say that one combination of assets is better than another, or that any asset class should be avoided. The figures are historical data from public indices: they exclude costs, taxes and the exchange-rate effect for an investor in Chile, and they do not anticipate future results.
Index data as of 30 December 2022 and inflation data as of December 2022; sources accessed 2 October 2026.
Questions and answers
How much did US stocks and bonds fall in 2022?
The S&P 500, with dividends reinvested, ended 2022 at −18.11%, and the Bloomberg US Aggregate bond index at −13.01%, both in US dollars. Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices and Bloomberg, via BlackRock fact sheets as of 30 Jun 2026; data as of 30 Dec 2022. Historical data; not indicative of future results.
Why didn't bonds offset stocks in 2022?
Because the dominant cause was the same for both: high inflation and rate increases. A higher rate lowers the price of bonds already issued and reduces the present value of companies' future profits. When the main concern is falling activity, the two parts usually react to different causes. This is typical behaviour, not guaranteed.
Sources
- S&P 500 (total return, USD), 2022: «Benchmark» row of BlackRock's iShares Core S&P 500 ETF fact sheet, as of 30 Jun 2026
- Bloomberg US Aggregate Bond Index (total return, USD), 2022: «Benchmark» row of BlackRock's iShares Core U.S. Aggregate Bond ETF fact sheet, as of 30 Jun 2026
- MSCI ACWI Index (net return, USD): MSCI fact sheet as of 31 Aug 2026
- US Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI for June 2022 (released 13 Jul 2022)
- US Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI for December 2022 (released 12 Jan 2023)
- INE Chile, IPC for December 2022 (released 6 Jan 2023)
- Federal Reserve, FOMC statement of 16 Mar 2022
- Federal Reserve, FOMC statement of 14 Dec 2022
Newsletter
Stay up to date with Athena's publications and market insights.
Athena Quantitative Strategies is a quantitative investment firm based in Santiago, Chile: it manages portfolios, publishes its market analysis and offers the software it uses to trade and research. Athena Quantitative Strategies is not registered in the CMF's Register of Portfolio Managers and is not supervised by it. This content is educational and informational; it is not investment advice, a recommendation or an offer of securities. All investing involves risk, including loss of capital.
